AI hasn’t disappeared, but the hype has cooled. And that’s a good thing. Leaders have an opportunity to move from experimentation to execution as pilots stall and ROI questions get louder. Let’s explore why many AI initiatives fall short and how organizations can reset expectations to deliver real business impact.
AI is still everywhere, but the tone has changed.
Conversations felt like a race a year ago. Leaders wanted something live, and fast. Teams were under pressure to prove value in weeks. Vendors were promising transformation. Executives imagined an intelligent co-worker that could manage complex work with minimal oversight.
The mood is more measured now: Fewer bold claims. More questions about cost, risk, and return. More stories about pilots that never became production. More leaders quietly asking, “Why isn’t this showing up in the numbers?”
That shift isn’t a failure. It’s progress.
It signals a move from hype to capability, and it creates space for practical decisions that lead to results.
The AI productivity paradox is real
Every major technology wave goes through a phase where adoption outpaces measurable productivity. Think personal computers, or the internet.
AI is doing the same thing now.
Teams can see immediate benefits in pockets of the business. Tasks get done faster, information becomes easier to access, and people spend less time on repetitive work. The impact feels obvious in isolation. Then leadership looks for proof at scale.
That’s where things get uncomfortable. The value exists, but it’s uneven. Some teams benefit more than others. Some use cases scale cleanly. Others fall apart under real-world complexity. And many initiatives stall before they ever make it out of pilot.
This gap between excitement and results creates skepticism and pressure to overpromise.
Why so many AI initiatives stall
AI projects don’t fail for exotic reasons. They fail for familiar ones:
- Expectations drift.
What starts as a focused initiative quickly expands. If AI can do one thing well, people assume it can do everything. Scope grows faster than governance.
- Success criteria stay vague.
“Innovation” and “transformation” sound compelling. They don’t help when trade-offs appear. It becomes hard to defend investment or prioritize effort without clear measures of success.
- Ownership is unclear.
AI introduces a new question: Who is responsible for the outcome? Who owns the decision if a model makes a recommendation or takes an action? Adoption slows when accountability is fuzzy.
- The organization expects compliance, not probability.
Many leaders imagine AI as a deterministic system, but most AI behaves like a probabilistic assistant. Disappointment sets in when it doesn’t act like a perfect employee.
- The pre-work is underestimated.
AI doesn’t remove the need for data discipline, process design, or governance. It exposes gaps faster. Teams that skip the groundwork pay for it later.
Looking for even more information on how to make AI work for your business?
Grab your copy of our free resource → Priced By Intelligence: 5 Ways AI Is Shaping the Future of Strategic Pricing
What actually works in practice
The AI programs that survive aren’t the flashiest but the most deliberate. They start with a real business problem, define what “good” looks like, constrain what the AI can touch, and build validation into the workflow from day one.
That approach may sound less exciting, but it delivers more.
1. Start with a real need
AI should solve a problem that already exists. Not one invented to justify a budget. If the need isn’t clear, the initiative becomes a demo. Demos don’t survive scrutiny.
2. Set expectations early and tightly
Define what the AI will do, what it won’t do, and acceptable accuracy and acceptable risk. This protects the business and the team implementing the solution.
3. Make success measurable
Not every benefit will show up as a clean ROI number immediately, and that’s okay. But you still need metrics that matter:
- Time saved
- Reaction latency reduced
- Coverage increased across long-tail products or customers
- Margin or revenue impact in controlled scenarios
- Fewer errors and manual handoffs
Honest metrics build credibility.
4. Design for change
AI costs won’t stay flat. Capacity won’t always be unlimited. Build modular workflows. Avoid designs that depend on infinite context. Make it possible to dial usage up or down without breaking the process.
5. Keep humans in the loop
This is about accountability. Validation builds trust. It also keeps explainability intact, and that’s critical in pricing and commercial decisions.
The opportunity in front of leaders
Execution begins when hype fades. This is the moment to stop chasing “AI everywhere” and start building “AI where it counts.”
The organizations that win aren’t the loudest but the most disciplined. They’ll:
- Pick narrow use cases that matter
- Define success clearly
- Carefully manage delegated authority
- Earn trust through outcomes
AI value doesn’t come from chasing trends. It comes from applying the right technology to the right problems, with clear expectations and measurable outcomes.
If you’re exploring how AI can drive real pricing and commercial impact in your organization, reach out to start the discussion. Our team can show you how leading manufacturers and distributors are moving beyond experimentation and into execution.
Schedule a demo to see what practical, scalable AI looks like in action.
Need more info on how to combat AI hype?
Check out the replay Chris Kennedy-Sloane’s webinar with EPP → Balancing Hype and Reality: How AI Can Drive the Next Wave of Intelligent Pricing
